Debate Forum Center 09/01/10

Debate Forum Center 09/01/10

A Historic Point For The U.S. Mission

President Obama is making good on his promise to end the U.S. combat mission in Iraq. As of August 31, all designated combat troops will have been out of Iraq and Operation Iraqi Freedom will have officially ended. The remaining 50,000 U.S forces still in Iraq are there to advise and assist brigades to continue the training of Iraq security forces. The Obama administration has set a goal of

December 31, 2011 for all U.S. troops to leave Iraq.

President Obama’s Iraq policy of bringing the U.S. presence to a conclusion has critics on both the left and right. Some critics on the left argue that, as a candidate, Obama pledged to completely withdraw all U.S. troops within nine months of taking office. In their view, this timetable has come and gone. They also believe there is nothing further to be gained from this misguided, and in the minds of some, illegal Bush war. In addition, they are disappointed that Obama isn’t simply pulling all U.S. troops out. They believe that nothing will stop the coming sectarian violence and that the continued presence of U.S. troops will delay and not prevent the all but certain civil war between the Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds. They particularly point to the fact that there is still no real plan to share power or the oil resources
between these groups.

Critics on the right believe that a continued U.S. presence will allow the fledgling and fragile Iraqi government to keep its footing while it finds a way to share power and enable democracy to take root. They believe that to leave prematurely will only ensure that those insurgents and members of the al-Qaeda terrorist groups, who have been standing down since the surge all but ended sectarian violence, will start up their murderous ways. In addition to challenging the government, these terrorists will again begin to slaughter innocent civilians. These critics argue that America has invested its blood and treasure to bring about a free and democratic government in Iraq, and it would be dishonorable to those who
sacrificed everything to allow the terrorists to regain control in Iraq.

Question Of The Week

In addition to withdrawing U.S. combat forces in Iraq, should President Obama immediately withdraw the balance of all U.S. troops in Iraq?

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Chew on this: 04/14

Banishing the blues with blueberries By Jayne Powers A change of seasons often signals a change in what we eat. Springtime […]

The Docket: 04/14

Dayton’s police blotter, reported verbatim A mirror misunderstanding Officers responded to a theft report in a grocery store parking lot. […]

Liberation literature

Yellow Springs author Virginia Hamilton leaves lasting impact By Erin Callahan Photo: Author Virginia Hamilton and her husband, poet Arnold […]

Advice Goddess: 4/14

By Amy Alkon Flee circus My mom left when I was young, and my former husband left me, too. Maybe […]

News of the weird: 04/14

By Chuck Shepherd Wait, what? An unarmed man, suspected of no crime, who three years ago was shot 16 times […]

Art meets Ag at Antioch College

AgriCULTURE exhibit at Herndon Gallery By Lisa Bennett Photo: Jeff Schmuki, Homestead III; photo: Dennie Eagleson What do agriculture and […]