Leaving fingerprints

Crooks on Tape steals hearts with pop mastery

By Tim Anderl

Photo: [l to r] John Schmersal, Joey Galvan and Rick Lee Crooks on Tape perform at Rockstar Pro Arena on Jan. 30

John Schmersal is perhaps best known to Dayton music aficionados and fans as one quarter of one of the Gem City’s most celebrated bands, Brainiac. When Brainiac ended, Schmersal’s next band, Enon, did much to light up the indie rock landscape with some of the same pop weirdness that Schmersal brought to Brainiac.

In the two decades since Brainiac’s Bonsai Superstar, Schmersal’s first record with the band, he has kept busy both behind the scenes and on stage. Between recording and producing select projects, he’s played with Caribou and Girls Against Boys, and in 2013 his improvised, avant garde pop project Crooks on Tape – with Rick Lee (Enon, Skeleton Key) and Joey Galvin – saw the light of day via Dayton’s Misra Records.

The unpredictable, enlightened record Fingerprint offered snapshots of the brilliance that happens when likeminded conspirators combine synthesizers, samplers, loopers and good ideas. Dayton City Paper caught up with Schmersal as Crooks on Tape prepared to bring Fingerprint to the masses during a winter 2014 tour. This is what he told us about the group and his former years in Dayton.

As of late, you’ve been dividing your time between Caribou and Girls and Against Boys, but Crooks is under your ownership. Was it different being back in the driver’s seat?

Yes it’s very different. In each of these bands I have a different role besides simply playing an instrument. With Crooks, that extends beyond into manager, organizer, webmaster, interview taker, etc. If you mean different from the way it was before, in the Enon days, it’s still pretty much the same.  -John Schmersal

Is this the first big collaboration you’ve done with Rick Lee since Enon?  

We’ve played music since he left Enon and pre-CoT periodically. But, I guess if you mean officially as far as the world is concerned or releases, then yes. -JS

Crooks recorded hundreds of hours of material during the creation of Fingerprint. What criteria did you use to decide what would make the final cut? 

It being our first album, we wanted to put some kind of pop face on what we were doing. There’s plenty of crazy jams and interesting soundscapes, and the goal was to find the most interesting pieces to bring together and make a cohesive listening experience. All three of us are fans of the long-play album format. So, the main thing was to make the album flow like a story unfolding. That being said, by today’s standards most listeners/bands/writers seem more comfortable with an album of songs that mines a limited pallet of sounds, or a series of songs that sound exactly the same all the way through. Crooks will never be guilty of this. -JS

I’m assuming Fingerprint was engineered by the band, correct? 

Ninety-five percent was, yes. I set up the gear in such a way that we could just arrive and begin to play/record with all the levels already set. Since we had no studio in 2013, we did record drums at a friend’s for a few tracks that ended up on the record. Otherwise, I recorded the vocals and did most of the choosing and editing at home or when I was on the road with Caribou.  -JS

Is there an element of improvisation that extends to the CoT live show? If so, how much of it is improvised?  

That is a very good question and conundrum for us. We never set out to be a band that replicated material from an album. The whole impetus from the outset was to improvise and record. Now we do none of these things since releasing Fingerprint. There will be some improvised pieces coupled with the record material and there will be unscripted improvised moments that take place in some of the album material as well. We want to keep it interesting for us and the audience. So there’ll be album material for those familiar, and also some improvisation to keep things exciting hopefully for everybody. This is the most exciting band I’ve been in because I literally don’t know what will happen next and that keeps it challenging for us all as well. -JS

How did you meet Leo Deluca (of Misra Records) and made the label a fit for this record? 

He reached out to me randomly and I began to share some of Crooks’ music with him at that point. It was one of those great “right place right time” kind of things. -JS

You are no stranger to Dayton, obviously. What made it a good proving ground during your formative years?

Proving ground? When I moved back to Dayton and joined Brainiac the waters were very fertile musically speaking. […] Guided by Voices,  Breeders, etc. But also, Dayton is/was a sleepy town where the riches could be found in the pawnshops and thrift stores, locally. This is pre-eBay. I think it was important to be in a city that had a tiny music buzz, but one that did not really affect the attitudes or egos of the band and allowed us to concentrate on just making original music and going on tour. Dayton is and was cheaper than most places to live. I paid a total of $67 per month for rent in 1995. -JS

Your Dayton show is with Swim Diver, which is Tyler Trent’s new band. Have you kept in consistent contact with him since Brainiac? Will this be the first time you’ve shared a stage in over a decade? 

Tyler and I have been in contact over the years and it is not the first time I will have shared a stage with him since Brainiac. When he was playing with The Dirty Walk, they supported Enon for some shows in the Midwest. -JS


Crooks on Tape will perform on Thursday, Jan. 30 at Rockstar Pro Arena, 1106 E. Third St. Also on the bill are Bearer of Bad News, Swarm and Swim Diver. Doors at 7 p.m. Admission is $10 and open to all ages. For more information, please visit crooksontapemusic.com.


Reach DCP freelance writer Tim Anderl at TimAnderl@DaytonCityPaper.com.

Tags: , ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Got an Opinion?


We are interested to hear what you think.  Please send us a message. [contact-form 4 “Opinion”]  

Plugged In

IMG_0400 (meijer)

The next sound you hear will be…well, I don’t know what it will be but I know what it won’t […]

Debate 6/12: A tweet too far


Was anyone really surprised? Roseanne Barr has stepped in it again. Always a loose cannon, she managed to offend just […]

If you’ve seen one ‘Ocean’, you’ve seen ‘Ocean’s 8’


Near the start of “Ocean’s 8,” we’re led to believe that Danny Ocean (George Clooney) is dead and his sister […]

Gin and Tonic on the Horizon


On June 13, The Rose Music Center is the place to be to get your 90s nostalgia fix as Gin […]

Goodnight Goodnight’s new morning


“We’ve known Larry for years,” says Gary Thornton of Goodnight Goodnight. He’s talking about the newest addition to their lineup, […]