Mysterious ways

The Mitchells are the enigmatic whole of unlikely parts

By Tim Anderl

Photo: The Mitchells will perform on Aug. 16 at South Park Tavern; photo: Jared Bowers

Cincinnati’s The Mitchells are a bit of an enigma. Tempering experience with classical performance and a history of performing in some of the region’s most celebrated independent rock bands with a deep, nerdy love of studio trickery and gear, the acoustic/electronic hybrid is organic, subtle and mysteriously hooky. Not quite a full-blown orchestral band, with hints of jazz-leanings and with a foot still placed in the world of indie rock, the band is winning over fans one at a time with their fresh approach.

Dayton City Paper recently spoke with band namesake Joseph William Mitchell about their new, self-titled record, playing festivals like Bunbury, beer and “dad rock.”

How would you describe the band in the context of the larger, indie landscape to people who haven’t heard you?

We jokingly call ourselves the inventors of “dad rock,” music that is a momentary quiet escape from the noise of the day. I think we sound familiar on first listen, pretty standard guitar-and-melody driven and organic indie, but the subtleties of melody, lyrics, dynamics and orchestration come out over time. We don’t sound like Iron & Wine, but I think we have that same kind of subtlety that creeps up on you, and at some point you finally hear the massive hooks that are hidden in the music. – Joseph William Mitchell

Your guitarist Marc Aiello is no stranger to Dayton, having played in Parker Ben Parker here in the ’90s.  How did he get involved in the band? 

Our drummer, Nick [Mavridoglou], and Marc are neighbors and had been friends for years. They had a weird Guided By Voices bond that only GBV fans think is not weird. They had done some casual jamming around, and were familiar with each others’ previous bands and recordings. 

Last summer, when The Mitchells were starting to think about expanding and developing their sound, remembering the kind of distinctive-yet-subtle guitar lines that Marc had done in Parker Ben Parker, Nick asked Marc if he would be interested in writing some parts. It all developed and evolved from there. It turned out to be a perfect match. – JWM

The new album took over a year to develop from start to finish. What was involved in that process?

Yeah, the new album took a winding path to completion. We tracked most of the basic songs in spring of 2013. When Marc entered the band in the fall, we revisited the orchestration and arrangement on some of them, and also wrote a few new ones. Once December hit, we did a huge push to finish all of the basic tracks, and then did a few months of tracking on the new instrumentation layers and with guest artists. Some of it was done in the big studio [All Nighter Recording Studio in Lebanon], some at Tommy’s [Cappell, engineer] studio, and some in Marc’s small studio. It was a blast, being able to work through the details as a band to get to a recording we’re super proud of. – JWM

How does the LP capture the live essence of the band?

It has that subtlety that initially hides the huge hooks, and the orchestra-like dynamic range that spends most of its time hiding silently in the grass, then occasionally jumps out and bites you. That was a weird snake metaphor. Really, on this album, the instrumentals are all built around the main guitar lines, which I play. They’re not lead lines or rhythm parts, they’re more like arpeggios or vamps from jazz parlance or continuo from orchestral music. They sound simple, but are filled with complex strumming and picking and lots of feel. Marc’s guitar lines are written mostly to fuse with mine, not like a traditional rhythm/lead. Like, you may not notice them, but if you took them out, the song would sound totally bare. There are a few places where there are identifiable guitar lead lines, but we use those sparingly. They have greater impact that way. – JWM

Noah Wotherspoon plays on the album right? How did he get involved in the record?

Noah and I met back in the younger years and remained friends. When we were looking for some distinctive voices for the album, Noah’s slide genius seemed like a perfect addition. We’re still just blown away every time we listen to it. Noah’s dreamy slide work give the song a real hazy, swirly, dreamy feel that blends all of the other parts together. He’s from another musical planet. – JWM

I noticed you guys are playing at Rhinegeist Brewery. If someone were to brew a namesake Mitchells beer, what would it be like?

We like beer. Some of us are more nerdy about beer than others, but on the whole, it’s not hard to catch us having a few beers together. Mitchells beer, hmmm … actually, it would be like some of Rhinegeist’s beers. It would start off pleasant, not hitting you in the face, and maybe have you wondering why it isn’t more flavorful. But by the fourth or fifth sip, you start to get it. By the end of the can, you’re tasting all kinds of flavors you didn’t notice at first. And then ordering another one. – JWM

The Mitchells have been invited to play some pretty big deal events lately, like MidPoint Music Festival and Bunbury Music Festival. What were those events like for you?  

In one way, surreal. It’s obviously an honor to be selected and to share stages with some of the most respected names in the national and local indie scenes. In another way, we just treat them like another opportunity connect to people with our music, connect with each other on stage and to just let go and enjoy the experience. – JWM

The Mitchells perform on Saturday, Aug. 16 at South Park Tavern, 1301 Wayne Ave. The 1984 Draft is also on the bill. Doors at 9 p.m. Admission is $5 for all ages. For more information, please visit

Reach DCP freelance writer Tim Anderl at

Tags: , ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Got an Opinion?


We are interested to hear what you think.  Please send us a message. [contact-form 4 “Opinion”]  

No Jet Engines Here


The very first thing is to learn how to pronounce it. No rhyming with the home of Baylor University in […]

Debate 9/11: Let’s Make Tammany Hall Great Again

cartoon cmyk

Third Parties have long complained that having the two major parties in charge of the election process gives Republicans and […]



No music and arts festival would truly be complete without… wrestling, right? Well, this year at Ladyfest Dayton, buckle down […]

Lives-in-progress, demo-style


Right from the start of this Jesse Peretz adaptation of Nick Hornby’s novel Juliet, Naked, there’s something warm and unfinished […]

Are ‘Friends” Electric?


Gary Numan’s Savage return to form at CVG’s Bogart’s Gary Numan with daughter Persia, who sings on the new single […]